EVENT>Novice Pairs |SESSION>Thursday Morn|SECTION> A N-S ------------------------,------ ------------,-------- -------------------------- DATE>February 6, 2020 |CLUB NO.>237719 | 02/06/2020 10:59 ---------------------,-- ------------------- -------------,--------------------- DIR> Maria Davis |RATING>Club Masterpoint (50%, 50%, 30% Open)|MOVEMENT>MITCHELL ------------,-------- ,-------------------------,--------- --------------------- AVE> 56.0 |TOP> 7 |MP LIMITS>100/20/5 |CLUB>Sun Lakes DBC ------------ --------- ------------------------- ------------------------------- PAIRS IN STRAT A=13/B=6/C=3 ,---,-------------------------,------,---------, -------------------------------------------------| | Section | |Section | No Name Name |Flt|Rnk-A|Rnk-B|Rnk-C| Score | Pct |Awards | ------------------------------------------------- --- ----- ----- ----- ------- ------ --------- 1 Julia Collier Frances Kliger A . . . 42.56 38.00 2 Amy Skinner Ilene Ouradnik A . . . 55.37 49.44 3 Cindy Kerr Pamela Runner C . . . 54.00 48.21 4 Edie Leo Mary Ann McFarlane A . . . 53.15 47.46 5 Rose Gangel Karen Rozanoff C 1 1 1 71.01 63.40 0.65(A) 6 Julie Eckerman Ann-Therese O'Sullivan C 2 2 . 67.87 60.60 0.46(A) 7 LaVonne Holmes Pam Gerstner A 3 . . 67.72 60.46 0.33(A) 8 Pam Bangen David Bangen B 4 . . 62.50 55.80 0.23(A) 9 Rich Schager Bernie Emery B 5 . . 55.49 49.54 0.13(A) 10 Barbara Smith Romelle Durand B . . . 45.64 40.75 11 Pat Schlecht Elise Marucchi-Soos A . . . 51.43 45.92 12 Patricia Potter Carole Kemps A NE . . 46.00 41.07 Totals 672.74 EVENT>Novice Pairs |SESSION>Thursday Morn|SECTION> A E-W ------------------------,------ ------------,-------- -------------------------- DATE>February 6, 2020 |CLUB NO.>237719 | 02/06/2020 10:59 ---------------------,-- ------------------- -------------,--------------------- DIR> Maria Davis |RATING>Club Masterpoint (50%, 50%, 30% Open)|MOVEMENT>MITCHELL ------------,-------- ,-------------------------,--------- --------------------- AVE> 56.0 |TOP> 7 |MP LIMITS>100/20/5 |CLUB>Sun Lakes DBC ------------ --------- ------------------------- ------------------------------- PAIRS IN STRAT A=13/B=9/C=7 ,---,-------------------------,------,---------, -------------------------------------------------| | Section | |Section | No Name Name |Flt|Rnk-A|Rnk-B|Rnk-C| Score | Pct |Awards | ------------------------------------------------- --- ----- ----- ----- ------- ------ --------- 1 Kitchie Julien R.W. Heckel A . . . 42.00 37.50 2 John Firebaugh Linda Firebaugh C . . . 50.92 45.46 3 Vesta Hayden Karen Groth A . . . 43.71 39.03 4 Linda Hufnagel Michael Hufnagel C . . . 39.70 35.45 5 Ruth Sorensen Al Sorensen C . . . 53.92 48.14 6 Cathie Bonnell Charles Bonnell B . . . 53.95 48.17 7 Stephen Betts George Hofer A 4 . . 62.79 56.06 0.23(A) 8 Peter Harris Melissa Denton A 1 . . 82.05 73.26 0.65(A) 9 Maria Patterson Carol Ann Marusiak B 5 3 . 59.35 52.99 0.23(B) 10 Dale Ehrbright Mercedes Johnson C . . . 53.87 48.10 11 Wendy Gale Foster Goldman C 2 1 1 69.87 62.38 0.46(A) 12 Bankim Dhanak Tom Brand C 3 2 2 64.90 57.95 0.33(A) 13 Joyce Johnson Renee Lies C . 4 3 56.90 50.80 0.16(B) Totals 733.93 RESULTS OF BOARD 1 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 140 6.93 0.07 1-Collier-Kliger vs 1-Julien-Heckel 110 2.93 4.07 7-Holmes-Gerstner vs 13-Johnson-Lies 110 2.93 4.07 8-Bangen-Bangen vs 2-Firebaugh-Firebaugh 110 5.21 1.79 9-Schager-Emery vs 4-Hufnagel-Hufnagel 130 1.21 5.79 10-Smith-Durand vs 6-Bonnell-Bonnell 150 0.07 6.93 11-Schlecht-Marucchi-Soos vs 8-Harris-Denton 110 5.21 1.79 12-Potter-Kemps vs 10-Ehrbright-Johnson ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 2 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 150 1.21 5.79 1-Collier-Kliger vs 1-Julien-Heckel 200 0.07 6.93 7-Holmes-Gerstner vs 13-Johnson-Lies 50 6.36 0.64 8-Bangen-Bangen vs 2-Firebaugh-Firebaugh 90 4.64 2.36 9-Schager-Emery vs 4-Hufnagel-Hufnagel 110 3.50 3.50 10-Smith-Durand vs 6-Bonnell-Bonnell 50 6.36 0.64 11-Schlecht-Marucchi-Soos vs 8-Harris-Denton 130 2.36 4.64 12-Potter-Kemps vs 10-Ehrbright-Johnson ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 3 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 50 5.21 1.79 1-Collier-Kliger vs 13-Johnson-Lies 110 1.79 5.21 2-Skinner-Ouradnik vs 2-Firebaugh-Firebaugh 50 5.21 1.79 8-Bangen-Bangen vs 1-Julien-Heckel 50 5.21 1.79 9-Schager-Emery vs 3-Hayden-Groth 110 1.79 5.21 10-Smith-Durand vs 5-Sorensen-Sorensen 50 5.21 1.79 11-Schlecht-Marucchi-Soos vs 7-Betts-Hofer 130 0.07 6.93 12-Potter-Kemps vs 9-Patterson-Marusiak ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 4 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 650 4.07 2.93 1-Collier-Kliger vs 13-Johnson-Lies 200 0.07 6.93 2-Skinner-Ouradnik vs 2-Firebaugh-Firebaugh 650 4.07 2.93 8-Bangen-Bangen vs 1-Julien-Heckel 650 4.07 2.93 9-Schager-Emery vs 3-Hayden-Groth 650 4.07 2.93 10-Smith-Durand vs 5-Sorensen-Sorensen 650 4.07 2.93 11-Schlecht-Marucchi-Soos vs 7-Betts-Hofer 650 4.07 2.93 12-Potter-Kemps vs 9-Patterson-Marusiak ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 5 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 200 5.21 1.79 1-Collier-Kliger vs 12-Dhanak-Brand 480 1.21 5.79 2-Skinner-Ouradnik vs 1-Julien-Heckel 170 6.93 0.07 3-Kerr-Runner vs 3-Hayden-Groth 200 5.21 1.79 9-Schager-Emery vs 2-Firebaugh-Firebaugh 450 2.36 4.64 10-Smith-Durand vs 4-Hufnagel-Hufnagel 420 3.50 3.50 11-Schlecht-Marucchi-Soos vs 6-Bonnell-Bonnell 510 0.07 6.93 12-Potter-Kemps vs 8-Harris-Denton ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 6 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 600 1.79 5.21 1-Collier-Kliger vs 12-Dhanak-Brand 200 6.93 0.07 2-Skinner-Ouradnik vs 1-Julien-Heckel 620 0.07 6.93 3-Kerr-Runner vs 3-Hayden-Groth 190 3.50 3.50 9-Schager-Emery vs 2-Firebaugh-Firebaugh 150 4.64 2.36 10-Smith-Durand vs 4-Hufnagel-Hufnagel 600 1.79 5.21 11-Schlecht-Marucchi-Soos vs 6-Bonnell-Bonnell 100 5.79 1.21 12-Potter-Kemps vs 8-Harris-Denton ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 7 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 660 0.64 6.36 1-Collier-Kliger vs 11-Gale-Goldman 100 5.79 1.21 2-Skinner-Ouradnik vs 13-Johnson-Lies 130 3.50 3.50 3-Kerr-Runner vs 2-Firebaugh-Firebaugh 300 6.93 0.07 4-Leo-McFarlane vs 4-Hufnagel-Hufnagel 130 3.50 3.50 10-Smith-Durand vs 3-Hayden-Groth 130 3.50 3.50 11-Schlecht-Marucchi-Soos vs 5-Sorensen-Sorensen 660 0.64 6.36 12-Potter-Kemps vs 7-Betts-Hofer ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 8 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 130 0.07 6.93 1-Collier-Kliger vs 11-Gale-Goldman 110 6.36 0.64 2-Skinner-Ouradnik vs 13-Johnson-Lies 110 6.36 0.64 3-Kerr-Runner vs 2-Firebaugh-Firebaugh PASS 4.64 2.36 4-Leo-McFarlane vs 4-Hufnagel-Hufnagel 90 2.93 4.07 10-Smith-Durand vs 3-Hayden-Groth 90 2.93 4.07 11-Schlecht-Marucchi-Soos vs 5-Sorensen-Sorensen 100 1.21 5.79 12-Potter-Kemps vs 7-Betts-Hofer ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 9 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 170 4.64 2.36 1-Collier-Kliger vs 10-Ehrbright-Johnson 140 2.93 4.07 2-Skinner-Ouradnik vs 12-Dhanak-Brand 200 6.36 0.64 3-Kerr-Runner vs 1-Julien-Heckel 100 1.21 5.79 4-Leo-McFarlane vs 3-Hayden-Groth 200 6.36 0.64 5-Gangel-Rozanoff vs 5-Sorensen-Sorensen 100 0.07 6.93 11-Schlecht-Marucchi-Soos vs 4-Hufnagel-Hufnagel 140 2.93 4.07 12-Potter-Kemps vs 6-Bonnell-Bonnell ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 10 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 200 1.79 5.21 1-Collier-Kliger vs 10-Ehrbright-Johnson 200 1.79 5.21 2-Skinner-Ouradnik vs 12-Dhanak-Brand 230 3.50 3.50 3-Kerr-Runner vs 1-Julien-Heckel 650 6.93 0.07 4-Leo-McFarlane vs 3-Hayden-Groth 300 4.64 2.36 5-Gangel-Rozanoff vs 5-Sorensen-Sorensen 170 0.07 6.93 11-Schlecht-Marucchi-Soos vs 4-Hufnagel-Hufnagel 620 5.79 1.21 12-Potter-Kemps vs 6-Bonnell-Bonnell ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 11 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 50 4.07 2.93 1-Collier-Kliger vs 9-Patterson-Marusiak 120 0.07 6.93 2-Skinner-Ouradnik vs 11-Gale-Goldman 100 1.21 5.79 3-Kerr-Runner vs 13-Johnson-Lies 90 2.36 4.64 4-Leo-McFarlane vs 2-Firebaugh-Firebaugh 140 6.36 0.64 5-Gangel-Rozanoff vs 4-Hufnagel-Hufnagel 50 4.07 2.93 6-Eckerman-O'Sullivan vs 6-Bonnell-Bonnell 140 6.36 0.64 12-Potter-Kemps vs 5-Sorensen-Sorensen ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 12 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 140 1.79 5.21 1-Collier-Kliger vs 9-Patterson-Marusiak 110 6.36 0.64 2-Skinner-Ouradnik vs 11-Gale-Goldman 100 4.07 2.93 3-Kerr-Runner vs 13-Johnson-Lies 140 1.79 5.21 4-Leo-McFarlane vs 2-Firebaugh-Firebaugh 110 6.36 0.64 5-Gangel-Rozanoff vs 4-Hufnagel-Hufnagel 100 4.07 2.93 6-Eckerman-O'Sullivan vs 6-Bonnell-Bonnell 170 0.07 6.93 12-Potter-Kemps vs 5-Sorensen-Sorensen ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 13 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 100 0.64 6.36 1-Collier-Kliger vs 8-Harris-Denton 200 6.93 0.07 2-Skinner-Ouradnik vs 10-Ehrbright-Johnson 100 0.64 6.36 3-Kerr-Runner vs 12-Dhanak-Brand 100 2.36 4.64 4-Leo-McFarlane vs 1-Julien-Heckel 140 5.79 1.21 5-Gangel-Rozanoff vs 3-Hayden-Groth 110 4.07 2.93 6-Eckerman-O'Sullivan vs 5-Sorensen-Sorensen 110 4.07 2.93 7-Holmes-Gerstner vs 7-Betts-Hofer ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 14 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 450 1.21 5.79 1-Collier-Kliger vs 8-Harris-Denton 300 2.93 4.07 2-Skinner-Ouradnik vs 10-Ehrbright-Johnson 600 0.07 6.93 3-Kerr-Runner vs 12-Dhanak-Brand 300 2.93 4.07 4-Leo-McFarlane vs 1-Julien-Heckel 100 5.79 1.21 5-Gangel-Rozanoff vs 3-Hayden-Groth 200 4.64 2.36 6-Eckerman-O'Sullivan vs 5-Sorensen-Sorensen 400 6.93 0.07 7-Holmes-Gerstner vs 7-Betts-Hofer ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 15 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 50 1.50 5.50 1-Collier-Kliger vs 7-Betts-Hofer 100 4.50 2.50 2-Skinner-Ouradnik vs 9-Patterson-Marusiak 100 4.50 2.50 3-Kerr-Runner vs 11-Gale-Goldman 200 0.00 7.00 4-Leo-McFarlane vs 13-Johnson-Lies 100 4.50 2.50 5-Gangel-Rozanoff vs 2-Firebaugh-Firebaugh 500 7.00 0.00 6-Eckerman-O'Sullivan vs 4-Hufnagel-Hufnagel 50 1.50 5.50 7-Holmes-Gerstner vs 6-Bonnell-Bonnell 100 4.50 2.50 8-Bangen-Bangen vs 8-Harris-Denton ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 16 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 200 1.79 5.21 1-Collier-Kliger vs 7-Betts-Hofer 140 5.21 1.79 2-Skinner-Ouradnik vs 9-Patterson-Marusiak 200 1.79 5.21 3-Kerr-Runner vs 11-Gale-Goldman 170 3.50 3.50 4-Leo-McFarlane vs 13-Johnson-Lies 140 5.21 1.79 5-Gangel-Rozanoff vs 2-Firebaugh-Firebaugh 50 6.93 0.07 7-Holmes-Gerstner vs 6-Bonnell-Bonnell 620 0.07 6.93 8-Bangen-Bangen vs 8-Harris-Denton ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 17 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 420 0.50 6.50 2-Skinner-Ouradnik vs 8-Harris-Denton 200 4.00 3.00 3-Kerr-Runner vs 10-Ehrbright-Johnson 150 7.00 0.00 4-Leo-McFarlane vs 12-Dhanak-Brand 300 2.00 5.00 5-Gangel-Rozanoff vs 1-Julien-Heckel 260 3.00 4.00 6-Eckerman-O'Sullivan vs 3-Hayden-Groth 150 5.00 2.00 7-Holmes-Gerstner vs 5-Sorensen-Sorensen 100 6.00 1.00 8-Bangen-Bangen vs 7-Betts-Hofer 420 0.50 6.50 9-Schager-Emery vs 9-Patterson-Marusiak ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 18 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 130 2.00 5.00 2-Skinner-Ouradnik vs 8-Harris-Denton 130 2.00 5.00 3-Kerr-Runner vs 10-Ehrbright-Johnson 50 6.00 1.00 4-Leo-McFarlane vs 12-Dhanak-Brand 130 2.00 5.00 5-Gangel-Rozanoff vs 1-Julien-Heckel 50 6.00 1.00 6-Eckerman-O'Sullivan vs 3-Hayden-Groth 150 0.00 7.00 7-Holmes-Gerstner vs 5-Sorensen-Sorensen 50 6.00 1.00 8-Bangen-Bangen vs 7-Betts-Hofer 110 4.00 3.00 9-Schager-Emery vs 9-Patterson-Marusiak ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 19 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 170 5.00 2.00 3-Kerr-Runner vs 9-Patterson-Marusiak 150 3.50 3.50 4-Leo-McFarlane vs 11-Gale-Goldman 140 1.50 5.50 5-Gangel-Rozanoff vs 13-Johnson-Lies 180 6.00 1.00 6-Eckerman-O'Sullivan vs 2-Firebaugh-Firebaugh 140 1.50 5.50 7-Holmes-Gerstner vs 4-Hufnagel-Hufnagel 300 7.00 0.00 8-Bangen-Bangen vs 6-Bonnell-Bonnell 90 0.00 7.00 9-Schager-Emery vs 8-Harris-Denton 150 3.50 3.50 10-Smith-Durand vs 10-Ehrbright-Johnson ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 20 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 140 4.00 3.00 3-Kerr-Runner vs 9-Patterson-Marusiak 650 0.00 7.00 4-Leo-McFarlane vs 11-Gale-Goldman 100 6.00 1.00 5-Gangel-Rozanoff vs 13-Johnson-Lies 140 4.00 3.00 6-Eckerman-O'Sullivan vs 2-Firebaugh-Firebaugh 200 7.00 0.00 7-Holmes-Gerstner vs 4-Hufnagel-Hufnagel 620 1.00 6.00 8-Bangen-Bangen vs 6-Bonnell-Bonnell 200 2.00 5.00 9-Schager-Emery vs 8-Harris-Denton 140 4.00 3.00 10-Smith-Durand vs 10-Ehrbright-Johnson ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 21 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 50 2.50 4.50 4-Leo-McFarlane vs 10-Ehrbright-Johnson 100 5.00 2.00 5-Gangel-Rozanoff vs 12-Dhanak-Brand 100 5.00 2.00 6-Eckerman-O'Sullivan vs 1-Julien-Heckel 100 5.00 2.00 7-Holmes-Gerstner vs 3-Hayden-Groth 140 1.00 6.00 8-Bangen-Bangen vs 5-Sorensen-Sorensen 300 0.00 7.00 9-Schager-Emery vs 7-Betts-Hofer 50 2.50 4.50 10-Smith-Durand vs 9-Patterson-Marusiak 150 7.00 0.00 11-Schlecht-Marucchi-Soos vs 11-Gale-Goldman ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 22 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 650 1.50 5.50 4-Leo-McFarlane vs 10-Ehrbright-Johnson 620 4.50 2.50 5-Gangel-Rozanoff vs 12-Dhanak-Brand 200 7.00 0.00 6-Eckerman-O'Sullivan vs 1-Julien-Heckel 600 6.00 1.00 7-Holmes-Gerstner vs 3-Hayden-Groth 650 1.50 5.50 8-Bangen-Bangen vs 5-Sorensen-Sorensen 650 1.50 5.50 9-Schager-Emery vs 7-Betts-Hofer 620 4.50 2.50 10-Smith-Durand vs 9-Patterson-Marusiak 650 1.50 5.50 11-Schlecht-Marucchi-Soos vs 11-Gale-Goldman ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 23 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 100 5.00 2.00 5-Gangel-Rozanoff vs 11-Gale-Goldman 110 6.50 0.50 6-Eckerman-O'Sullivan vs 13-Johnson-Lies 140 2.00 5.00 7-Holmes-Gerstner vs 2-Firebaugh-Firebaugh 110 4.00 3.00 8-Bangen-Bangen vs 4-Hufnagel-Hufnagel 140 2.00 5.00 9-Schager-Emery vs 6-Bonnell-Bonnell 170 0.00 7.00 10-Smith-Durand vs 8-Harris-Denton 110 6.50 0.50 11-Schlecht-Marucchi-Soos vs 10-Ehrbright-Johnson 140 2.00 5.00 12-Potter-Kemps vs 12-Dhanak-Brand ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 24 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 420 0.00 7.00 5-Gangel-Rozanoff vs 11-Gale-Goldman 170 1.00 6.00 6-Eckerman-O'Sullivan vs 13-Johnson-Lies 50 5.50 1.50 7-Holmes-Gerstner vs 2-Firebaugh-Firebaugh 50 7.00 0.00 8-Bangen-Bangen vs 4-Hufnagel-Hufnagel 50 5.50 1.50 9-Schager-Emery vs 6-Bonnell-Bonnell 140 3.00 4.00 10-Smith-Durand vs 8-Harris-Denton 140 3.00 4.00 11-Schlecht-Marucchi-Soos vs 10-Ehrbright-Johnson 140 3.00 4.00 12-Potter-Kemps vs 12-Dhanak-Brand ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 25 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 50 1.21 5.79 6-Eckerman-O'Sullivan vs 12-Dhanak-Brand 670 6.93 0.07 7-Holmes-Gerstner vs 1-Julien-Heckel 420 4.07 2.93 8-Bangen-Bangen vs 3-Hayden-Groth 450 5.79 1.21 9-Schager-Emery vs 5-Sorensen-Sorensen 110 0.07 6.93 10-Smith-Durand vs 7-Betts-Hofer 420 4.07 2.93 11-Schlecht-Marucchi-Soos vs 9-Patterson-Marusiak 100 2.36 4.64 12-Potter-Kemps vs 11-Gale-Goldman ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 26 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 200 0.07 6.93 6-Eckerman-O'Sullivan vs 12-Dhanak-Brand 680 6.36 0.64 7-Holmes-Gerstner vs 1-Julien-Heckel 620 1.79 5.21 8-Bangen-Bangen vs 3-Hayden-Groth 680 6.36 0.64 9-Schager-Emery vs 5-Sorensen-Sorensen 650 4.07 2.93 10-Smith-Durand vs 7-Betts-Hofer 620 1.79 5.21 11-Schlecht-Marucchi-Soos vs 9-Patterson-Marusiak 650 4.07 2.93 12-Potter-Kemps vs 11-Gale-Goldman ----------------------------------------------------------------------